Inside Antiques
Column Archives
 
2010
 
Motorcycles
 
Dressing tables
 
Art nouveau
 
2009
 
Hubley toys
 
Victorian glass
 
Garden seeds
 
Collectible knives
 
Antique boxes
 
Mechanical Valentines
 
2008
 
Christmas collectibles
 
Black cat collectibles
 
Picnic memorabilia
 
Cat collectibles
 
Buttons, buttons
 
2007
 
Christmas angels
 
Victorian sewing
 
2006
 
Ice cream
 
Syrup jugs
 
Inside Antiques, by Robert Reed
 
Inside Antiques:
17th century homemade butter launched collectibles
 
By Robert Reed
Butter making was a big deal in 19th century America, and so was the ultimate serving of it. One result of its importance are the related antiques and collectibles left in its wake.
 
And the practice was not entirely confined to that century. Making butter at home begun as early as the 17th century in the Colonies and was continued in many parts of the United States as late as the 1940s.
 
During the 1800s many families even in non-rural areas kept one or two cows simply to provide a steady supply of dairy products. Extra butter could be readily marketed in neighboring towns.
 
Butter chums were of course essential in the production process. Early barrel-shaped churns were wooded and often held together with wood hoops. Makers would manually move the broom-like handle of the dasher up and down stirring the milk inside and forming butter on the paddles of the dasher. Later chums were made of various materials including copper, glass, metal, and stoneware. Most of these churns, although they stood in many homes, were either homemade or not identified by maker.
 
However a few commercial makers did properly mark their churns. Among them were Mosely and Pritchard Manufacturing in Iowa, Aspinwall Manufacturing Co. in Michigan, Frank Jones in New York, Curtis and Green Manufacturing in Wisconsin, A. H. Reid of Pennsylvania, and Standard Churn Co. of Wapakonetta, Ohio.
 
During later years of the 19th century a majority of homemade butter was being churned in glass jars with mechanical beaters. However cylinder type wooden churns complete with iron cranks on the side remained available through mail-order catalogs well into the 1890s. The smaller and more compact glass jar churns survived in the long term and remained a 99 cent item in the Montgomery-Ward catalog in the 1920s. Stoneware butter churns were also still sold in the 1920s but were much more expensive. Still with hard maple dashers inside, the stoneware types ranged from $2 to $4 each.
 
Clearly butter making in America involved far more items than merely churns.
Molds, ladles, spades, paddles, butter prints and various wooden bowls were essential as well.
 
Early butter molds were hand constructed and hand carved and today represent some of the most sought items of American folk art. Some were bell-shaped and some were boxed with squared corners. By the second half of the 19th century molds were being produced in factories on lathes, however they were still attractive and still necessary to the overall process.
 
In 1872 the American Agriculturist offered information on a couple of fancy molds "by which butter may be put up into pound or half-pound cakes for the market. The molds themselves were described as "made of soft wood, as white-ash or soft maple, and they are generally kept for sale at all country stores where willow-ware is sold."
 
According to the Agriculturist, "when the butter is ready for making up, it is weighed out into proper quantities, and each piece is worked in the butter dish with the ladle into flat round cakes. The cakes are either pressed with the mold or made to go into the cup of another mold. When the handle is pressed down it forces the mold onto the butter, which is squeezed into a very near ornamental cake."
 
Generally basic molds held a plunger device which in turn held the butter stamp or print. The carved print symbol could be in the design of flowers, animals, birds, fruits, hearts, or other simple motifs.
 
Ladles of solid wood were major importance to the process too. In 1859 The Young Housekeeper's Friend observed, "for working butter, keep a wooden bowl and ladle. This last article is seldom found in New England, but always found in the state of New York. More than a half century later butter ladles, and butter paddles and spades were still being offered by catalog "in the New York style." Some experts maintain that butter originally made in New York was more heavily salted and therefore required and more specialized wooden tools to prepare it for making cakes and pastry.
 
Once the butter was crafted and prepared the fun was only beginning. Naturally such a treat had to be properly presented on the fashionable Victorian dining table.
 
Butter pats were in style in many homes. These small, flat dishes could be placed at each individual table setting. During the late 1890s and early 1900s they appeared in various delicate floral patterns, and were typically a matched set made of earthenware or porcelain. "Ironically," wrote Jean Minar Paris some years ago in A Field Guide to Antiques and Collectibles, "these were some of the first things to be lost or thrown out from the table service when things began to be passed down in the family. They were no longer used, they were too formal and cluttered up the now smaller dining tables, and their use passed in memory."
 
Meanwhile some very fine butter dishes made up part of an elaborate table service. They varied from low but sleek containers to large and decorative styles. Some of the larger ones usually sat on a raised stand, and were ornately designed in silver or silver plate. The very best had fancy swivel lids and came with special butter knives which matched the detailed design of the dish. Overall they were a striking object for the table and stood 12 to 15 inches in height. Other butter dishes could also be used. They were produced in virtually every pattern of fine china, and also could be found in distinguished glass.
 
Besides the formal place on the dining table, butter was also often kept in a clearly marked, large round crock in the household pantry or cool storehouse. These crocks, usually made of glazed stoneware, were very popular during the late 19th century but were strictly for storage and not for appearances at the table.
 
Thus from preparation to serving butter held a special place in the Victorian
household and in doing so left behind a treasure chest of related antiques and collectibles.
 
Photos:
1 - Wooden butter churn
 
2 - Star butter mold, with dove-tailed joints
 
3 - 19th century maple butter paddle/ladle
 
4 - Blue and white Victorian covered butter dish
 
Robert Reed has written on antiques and collectibles for more than two decades. He has also authored 15 books, including his recently released Antiques and Collectible Dictionary, available from www.collectorbooks.com
 
 
Return to top of page
 
This Is Livin' Publishing © 2010
581 8th Line West, RR1 Hastings, ON, K0L 1Y0
Phone/Fax: 705-696-1833
 
webmaster